№ 01 — The Cottage Bakery Branson, MO · 65616

New York Style.
Hand Rolled, Boiled & Baked.

Big, hand-rolled New York style bagels — cold-proofed overnight, boiled, and pulled from the oven in small batches. Plus real sourdough rounds and pan loaves. No preservatives. No conditioners. No shortcuts.

4 for $12 Bagels $12 Sourdough Loaf See the Menu
An assortment of freshly baked New York style bagels
The last bake Small batch · Branson, MO
№ 02 — The Board

Seven bagels.

↓ 01 · RegularScroll →
180g · NY Style Regular bagel
01

Regular

Naked and honest. The base recipe — nothing on top, nothing hiding.

Toppings — None

$3.50 ea4 / $12
180g · NY Style Everything bagel
02

Everything

Five toppings, flaked sea-salt finish. A small pantry per bagel.

Sesame · Poppy · Onion · Garlic · Salt

$3.50 ea4 / $12
180g · NY Style Sesame bagel
03

Sesame

Toasted sesame seeds, top and bottom. Nutty, fragrant, classic.

Toppings — Sesame

$3.50 ea4 / $12
180g · NY Style Poppy seed bagel
04

Poppy Seed

A dark, nutty blanket of poppy. Old-world quiet. Old-world good.

Toppings — Poppy

$3.50 ea4 / $12
180g · NY Style Onion bagel
05

Onion

Toasted onion flakes, caramelized dark in the bake. Savory and fragrant.

Toppings — Toasted Onion

$3.50 ea4 / $12
180g · Sweet Cinnamon raisin bagel
06

Cinnamon Raisin

Plump raisins folded through, warm cinnamon throughout the dough.

Mixed in — Cinnamon & Raisins

$3.50 ea4 / $12
Limited 180g · Sweet Cinnamon crunch bagel
07

Cinnamon Crunch

Saigon cinnamon and sugar, baked into a crackling caramelized crust.

Best-seller · Sells out fast

$3.50 ea4 / $12
Also on the board — Sourdough Rounds & Pan Loaves 24–36h ferment · round or pan · $12 See the full menu →

Simple pricing.

Prepay by Venmo, or pay in cash at pickup or drop-off.

Branson Bagels

Bake ticket · Branson, MO
  • NY Style Bagels (1)$3.50
  • NY Style Bagels (4-pack)$12.00
  • NY Style Bagels (half-dozen)$18.00
  • NY Style Bagels (dozen)$34.00
  • NY Style Bagels (baker's dozen · 13)$36.00
  • Sourdough · round or pan loaf$12.00
№ 03 — The Cottage Bakery

Bread the way it used to be.

One oven. A few bakes a week. Nothing you couldn't pronounce.

NYC-style bagels and real sourdough bread were nowhere to be found around here. The kind with a crackling crust, dense chew, and real tang — the kind you can't fake. So we decided to bring them to Branson ourselves.

We were tired of what "bread" had become — a list of ingredients as long as a receipt, sitting on a shelf for weeks without changing color. Real dough doesn't need any of that. Our bagels: water, the highest-quality flour, yeast, salt, and barley malt syrup. Our sourdough rounds and pan loaves: flour, water, salt, and a living starter. That's everything.

The barley malt syrup is the New York signature: it's what gives a real NY bagel that deep crust color and gentle sweetness — industrial "bagels" skip it and fake the color with caramel coloring. We don't.

Bagel dough is mixed the day before and cold-proofs overnight. Then every single bagel is hand rolled, boiled like a traditional New York bagel, and baked in small batches — about 180 grams of dough each before toppings. That's a serious bagel. It's a whole meal on its own.

We bake out of a licensed cottage kitchen right here in Branson. Because our batches are small, we sell them by text: we message the club, you reply, you pick up. That's the whole system. Simple, honest, and a little old-fashioned.

Don't miss the next batch.

Text Club subscribers get first notice on every bake day — new flavors, loaf drops, and holiday specials. No spam, just bread.